What is the ruling if the Cemerat are stoned in the wrong sequence?

On the days of Tashriq (11th-13th), the three Cemerat must be stoned in order: smallest (al-Sughra), middle (al-Wusta), then largest (al-Kubra/al-Aqabah). If a haci stones them in the wrong order, the majority of scholars (Shafi'i, Hanbali) require repeating the stoning in the correct sequence. The Hanafi school considers the sequence sunnet but not farz — stoning in wrong order is valid but disliked.

Last updated: 8 Mart 2026

What Is the Ruling?

On the days of Tashriq (11th, 12th, and 13th of Dhul-Hijjah), the three Cemerat must be stoned in a specific sequence: first the smallest Jamarah (al-Sughra/al-Ula), then the middle Jamarah (al-Wusta), then the largest Jamarah (al-Kubra/Jamrat al-Aqabah). On the 10th of Dhul-Hijjah, only Jamrat al-Aqabah is stoned, so the sequence issue does not arise.

The majority of scholars (Maliki, Shafi'i, Hanbali) hold that the correct sequence is farz (wajib) or even a condition (shart) for the validity of the stoning. If a haci stones them in the wrong order — for example, starting with the largest or middle Jamarah — they must repeat the stoning in the correct order. Sheikh Ibn Uthaymeen explained that Hz. Peygamber (sallallahu aleyhi ve sellem) stoned them in sequence and said 'Take your rites from me,' making his order binding.

The Hanafi school takes a more lenient position, holding that the sequence is Sunnah (sunnet) but not a condition of validity. According to this view, stoning in the wrong order is valid but contrary to the Sunnah, and no penalty or repetition is required. However, the haci misses the reward of following the prophetic sequence. Sheikh Ibn Baz followed the majority position and advised that if a haci discovers they have stoned in the wrong order and the day's stoning time has not ended, they should repeat the stoning in the correct sequence from the point where the order was broken.

What Is the Evidence for This Ruling?

Sahih al-Bukhari #1751Sahih

On the days of Tashriq, Hz. Peygamber (sallallahu aleyhi ve sellem) went to the Cemerat and stoned the first Jamarah with seven pebbles, saying 'Allahu Akbar' with each throw. Then he moved forward and made dua. Then he stoned the second Jamarah with seven pebbles, then moved forward and made dua. Then he stoned Jamrat al-Aqabah with seven pebbles and departed.

How Do Different Madhabs View This?

Scholars from different schools of Islamic jurisprudence offer varying perspectives on this matter.

Hanafi

The sequence of stoning is Sunnah, not farz. Stoning in the wrong order is valid but contrary to the sunnet practice. No repetition is required.

Al-Hidayah: the sequence is from the Sunnah, and omitting it does not invalidate the stoning.

Maliki

The Maliki school considers the sequence farz. Stoning in the wrong order requires repeating from the point of error while the stoning time remains.

Al-Mudawwanah: Imam Malik required the correct sequence for stoning the three Cemerat.

Shafi'i

The sequence is a condition (shart) for the validity of stoning according to the Shafi'i school. Stoning in the wrong order must be repeated in the correct sequence.

Al-Majmu' by al-Nawawi: 'The sequence of the three Cemerat is required, and stoning out of order is not counted.'

Hanbali

The Hanbali school considers the sequence wajib (farz). Stoning in the wrong order requires correction by repeating from the point of error.

Al-Mughni by Ibn Qudamah: 'The sequence in stoning the Cemerat is farz, based on Hz. Peygamber's consistent practice.'

This is a scholarly summary, not a personal fatwa. Consult your scholar for personal rulings.

Evidence & References

Hadith

Sahih al-Bukhari #1751 (sahih)

What is the ruling if the Cemerat are stoned in the wrong sequence?

What Is the Ruling?

What Is the Evidence for This Ruling?

How Do Different Madhabs View This?

Source

Evidence & References