Loading...
The most common الحج mistakes include: passing the الميقات without الإحرام, reciting fabricated الأدعية for each الطواف circuit, pushing to kiss the الحجر الأسود, standing outside عرفة boundaries, leaving عرفة before sunset, skipping مزدلفة, stoning all three الجمرات on the 10th, and shopping after the farewell الطواف. Each mistake has a specific remedy in the السنة.
The most common الإحرام mistakes include: (1) Passing the الميقات without entering الإحرام — the الحاج must return to the الميقات or pay فدية (sacrifice a sheep). (2) Believing الإحرام is the clothing rather than the intention — الإحرام is a state entered through niyyah, not by wearing white cloths. (3) Men wearing underwear, socks, or fitted shoes beneath الإحرام garments — these are violations that require فدية. (4) Women believing they must wear white or specific colors — women may wear any modest clothing. (5) Applying perfume to the الإحرام garments — perfume is only جائز on the body before making the niyyah, never on the garments. (6) Raising the voice in talbiyah for women — women should recite softly, not loudly. (7) Not making the conditional intention (ishtiraat) when there is a genuine fear of being prevented — النبي permitted Duba'ah bint al-Zubayr to add this condition (صحيح مسلم, 1207). (8) Believing that wearing الإحرام garments before the الميقات means being in الإحرام — wearing the garments without the intention does not initiate الإحرام.
Common الطواف errors include: (1) Reciting specific الأدعية for each circuit from books — there are NO authentic specific الأدعية assigned to individual circuits. The only أُسس دعاء for a specific location is 'Rabbana atina fi al-dunya hasanah...' between the Yemeni Corner and the الحجر الأسود. The rest of الطواف is for any دعاء or dhikr you wish. (2) Pushing and shoving to kiss or touch the الحجر الأسود — the السنة when crowded is to point toward it and say 'Allahu Akbar.' Harming others is sinful and negates the reward. (3) Walking clockwise — the الكعبة must ALWAYS be on your left side (counterclockwise). (4) Performing الرَّمَل (brisk walking) in all 7 circuits — الرَّمَل is only in the first 3 circuits and only in certain الطوافs. (5) Wiping the body on the الكعبة's walls or the مقام إبراهيم — there is no basis for this in the السنة. (6) Touching all four corners of the الكعبة — only the الحجر الأسود corner and the Yemeni Corner are touched in the السنة. (7) Praying the 2 ركعة of الطواف directly behind مقام إبراهيم when it blocks the الطواف path — the الصلاة may be performed anywhere in the مسجد. (8) Believing that الوضوء breaking during الطواف invalidates all previous circuits — the majority say you renew الوضوء and continue from where you stopped.
These are the most frequent errors pilgrims make during this stage of Hajj.
Scholarly references supporting this guidance from established Islamic sources.
Common السعي errors include: (1) Starting السعي at المروة instead of الصفا — السعي MUST begin at الصفا. النبي (صلى الله عليه وسلم) said: 'I begin with what Allah began with' and started at الصفا (صحيح مسلم, 1218). Starting at المروة means the first lap does not count. (2) Counting a round trip (الصفا to المروة and back) as one lap — each direction is one lap. الصفا to المروة = 1, المروة to الصفا = 2, and so on until 7, ending at المروة. (3) Women jogging between the green markers — only men jog; women walk normally throughout. (4) Raising the hands toward the الكعبة from الصفا/المروة as if praying — the hands are raised for دعاء, not for salah. (5) Climbing to the very top of الصفا or المروة — it is sufficient to reach the hill/marker and face the الكعبة; you need not climb the ancient hilltop. (6) Believing السعي requires الوضوء — الوضوء is مستحب but not required for السعي عند جمهور العلماء. (7) Performing السعي without completing الطواف first — السعي must follow a valid الطواف. (8) Running the entire distance between الصفا and المروة — only the section between the green markers requires jogging for men.
Critical errors at عرفة include: (1) Standing OUTSIDE the boundary of عرفة — this is the most catastrophic mistake because it invalidates the entire الحج. The boundaries are marked with signs. Verify your location. The مسجد of Namirah is partially outside عرفة — pray inside the boundary. (2) Leaving عرفة BEFORE sunset — النبي (صلى الله عليه وسلم) stayed until sunset (صحيح مسلم, 1218). Leaving before sunset requires a فدية (sacrifice) عند many scholars. (3) Fasting on the Day of عرفة while performing الحج — النبي did not fast at عرفة during الحج. Fasting on this day is for non-الحجاج. Umm Fadl sent a cup of milk to النبي on عرفة and he drank it, showing he was not fasting (صحيح البخاري, 1988). (4) Spending the day at عرفة in idle talk, sleeping excessively, or socializing instead of making دعاء — this is the greatest day of the year and the time for intensive الدعاء. (5) Facing the mountain of عرفة (Jabal al-Rahmah) instead of the القبلةh — face the القبلةh when making دعاء, not the mountain. (6) Climbing Jabal al-Rahmah, believing it has special virtue — there is no special virtue in climbing the mountain; النبي stood at the base near the rocks.
Common مزدلفة errors include: (1) Skipping the overnight stay at مزدلفة entirely without excuse — this is واجب, and missing it requires فدية. (2) Delaying Maghrib and Isha past their combined time — pray them as soon as you arrive, combined with one adhan and two iqamahs. Do not delay. (3) Praying nafl الصلوات between Maghrib and Isha — النبي (صلى الله عليه وسلم) did not pray any nafl between them at مزدلفة (صحيح البخاري, 1673). (4) Leaving مزدلفة before midnight without being among the weak, elderly, or women — the dispensation to leave early is only for those with valid excuses. (5) Spending excessive time collecting pebbles — you only need 7 for the first day; the rest can be collected at منى. Small pebbles the size of chickpeas are sufficient. (6) Washing the pebbles — there is no basis for washing them in the السنة. (7) Believing you must collect pebbles specifically from مزدلفة — pebbles may be collected from anywhere within the Haram boundaries.
Frequent stoning errors include: (1) Stoning all three الجمرات on the 10th of ذو الحجة — only الجمرات al-Aqaba (the large pillar) is stoned on the 10th. The small and middle pillars are stoned only on the 11th, 12th, and 13th. (2) Throwing large rocks or shoes — النبي (صلى الله عليه وسلم) said to use small pebbles the size of chickpeas (صحيح مسلم, 1299). (3) Stoning before noon (zawal) on the days of التشريق — the time for stoning on the 11th, 12th, and 13th begins after zawal عند the majority. Only the 10th has flexibility for stoning before noon. (4) Stoning in the wrong order on التشريق days — the correct order is small, middle, then large. Reversing the order requires re-stoning. (5) Not stopping for دعاء after the small and middle pillars — the السنة is to move aside, face the القبلةh, and make دعاء after stoning each of these two. (6) Making دعاء after stoning the large pillar — النبي did NOT make دعاء after الجمرات al-Aqaba. (7) Throwing all 7 pebbles at once — each pebble must be thrown separately with 'Allahu Akbar.' (8) Appointing a proxy for stoning without genuine inability — delegation is only permitted for the sick, elderly, pregnant women, and young children.
Common innovations and general mistakes include: (1) Visiting the graves of النبي's companions or other historical sites as acts of worship — visiting graves is for making دعاء for the deceased, not for seeking blessings from them. (2) Touching and wiping the walls of the الكعبة or مقام إبراهيم seeking barakah — only touching the الحجر الأسود and the Yemeni Corner is from the السنة. Umar ibn al-Khattab said about the الحجر الأسود: 'I know that you are a stone that neither harms nor benefits. Had I not seen النبي kiss you, I would not have kissed you' (صحيح البخاري, 1597). (3) Believing that الحج requires visiting المدينة — الحج is complete without visiting المدينة. Visiting النبي's المسجد is a separate meritorious act. (4) Performing specific numbers of الصلوات at specific spots in المسجد الحرام — there are no authentic narrations prescribing specific الصلاة counts at specific locations. (5) Group dhikr in unison during الطواف or at عرفة where one person chants and others repeat — each person should make their own individual دعاء. (6) Tying ribbons or cloth on fences near holy sites — this is a superstitious practice with no basis. (7) Shopping or conducting business after the farewell الطواف — the farewell الطواف must be the last act before departure.